Parking Takes Center Stage in West End Discussions

Staff will lead Traverse City commissioners through a series of focused discussions over several meetings designed to help them decide how to use six city-owned parcels on State and Pine streets. Once targeted for a third downtown parking deck, the properties are now being considered for a mix of uses including parking, housing, public restrooms, and a police substation.

Commissioners will focus on the topic of parking tonight (Monday), with two key issues shaping the discussion: a new legal opinion that the city must use the parcels for public parking or else reimburse the parking fund $7.6 million for their value, and a variety of upcoming projects that could eliminate up to 337 parking spaces downtown.

Commissioners issued a request-for-proposals (RFP) earlier this year to solicit development ideas for the properties, receiving two detailed responses. One was from John Socks under his company ShoreNorth Development in partnership with Great Lakes Capital, while the second came from Endeavour Traverse City Partners and includes partnerships with HomeStretch, Spence Brothers, and Kuhn Rogers. Both proposals included parking, housing, and other elements the city requested, though varied in the spaces/units offered and proposed ownership structures.

The city pumped the brakes on the RFP after numerous questions arose during review, from design constraints on the site to the city’s investment recoupment to whether a payment-in-lieu-of-taxes (PILOT) agreement could be used for housing.

“Rather than attempting to address all aspects of the proposals in a single discussion, the team has organized a series of focused study sessions to allow the commission to explore these goals in greater detail, understand the associated opportunities and challenges, and consider broader policy and financial implications before determining how best to move forward,” City Manager Benjamin Marentette wrote to commissioners.

Marentette said one “important consideration” when it comes to parking is the city’s $7.6 million investment in the west end properties, which were acquired in a series of deals over several years through the parking enterprise fund. According to Marentette, the city’s previous understanding was that the parcels could be used in a variety of ways so long as they had a recognized public benefit. However, an opinion from the city’s new legal counsel, The Kelly Firm, disputes that interpretation.

“The current guidance provides greater clarity that, should the properties be used for purposes other than public parking, the parking enterprise fund must be reimbursed through a purchase price or another legally recognized exchange of value,” Marentette wrote. “This could include a direct reimbursement or a structured transaction, depending on the terms and timing of repayment. This is a significant financial consideration that will need to be addressed as the commission evaluates potential redevelopment opportunities and balances the various goals identified for these properties.”

John Ryan of The Kelly Firm further clarified in a memo that if the “city commission were to reimburse the parking fund for the cost of purchasing the property, the limitation to public parking would no longer apply” – meaning the parcels could then be used for other purposes.

City Director of Communication & Strategic Initiatives Colleen Paveglio said in a presentation that parking decisions should also “consider the entire downtown system rather than individual properties or developments in isolation.” Changes to one parking lot “can affect availability, permits, revenues, and demand elsewhere,” she wrote. Surface parking lots are currently oversold downtown, with a moratorium on issuing any new surface parking permits. Certain metered areas are also experiencing usage “exceeding 90 percent,” according to Paveglio.

When commissioners consider current and future parking demands when deciding whether to build a deck – and the number of new spaces needed – Paveglio said other site considerations must come into play. There are several projects in the pipeline that could significantly reduce parking downtown. Those include taking away the existing surface parking spaces on the west end parcels (57 spaces), building the farmers market pavilion/reconstructing Lot B (35 spaces), and potentially reconstructing the alley between Rotary Square and FishPass (13-22 spaces).

The city has also discussed potentially removing the retaining wall in the 100 block alley of Front Street, which would redesign the alley and eliminate 68 spaces. Changing the flow of State Street as part of its two-way design to include mobility improvements like two-way bike lanes or intersection changes could impact up to 95 spaces, while a major downtown water main construction project in 2028 and 2029 could impact 60 spaces.

In total, those projects could mean a reduction of 337 parking spaces downtown. That would also result in an annual potential parking revenue loss of $459,000. The city’s original plan for a third downtown parking deck called for 534 spaces; ShoreNorth Development/Great Lakes Capital proposed that same amount in its RFP response, while Endeavour Traverse City Partners targeted 365 parking spaces. Commissioners will need to consider factors including capital costs, operating revenues, existing financial commitments, and broader public benefits – like housing, placemaking, and economic development – when weighing parking against other uses, Paveglio wrote.

Following tonight’s parking review, commissioners are expected to delve into three more topics at upcoming meetings. Those include housing and community needs (targeted for December 7), design/land use/public benefits, and proposal review/development opportunities. That final session will allow commissioners to revisit the two submitted proposals in light of their discussions and determine next steps, which could include choosing a proposal, asking developers to modify or update their plans, or going in a different direction entirely.

“There is no need to rush this process…ultimately, the question before us is not simply which development proposal to pursue, but what the city wants to accomplish with these properties and how we can best achieve those outcomes for the long-term benefit of the community,” Marentette wrote.