theTICKER
Traverse City News and Events
Thursday, April 24, 2014
Today's News
Share | RSS Feed  

Festival Fatigue Under Traverse City Microscope

September 23, 2013
Festival Fatigue Under Traverse City Microscope

Traverse City commissioners will debate a delicate tipping point tonight when they consider a possible tightening of guidelines for events and festivals on the city's waterfront. The commission will conduct a study session to review the city's events and park use policy after a crowded festival season provoked complaints from local residents.

Though the commission already overhauled the city's event policy once in the past year, officials are hoping to refine the guidelines further to eliminate recurring concerns. While it's unlikely action will be taken on any proposed changes tonight, commissioners will gather feedback from constituents, event promoters and city police to determine which aspects of the policy – if any – require revision.

City staff have compiled a series of recommended “substantive changes” to the event policy for commissioners to consider at the meeting, in addition to suggestions put forth by the public. Here's a look at the complaints most likely to arise – and how commissioners might address them.

Too Many Events
Commissioners attempted to resolve so-called “festival fatigue” in their first policy go-round by creating categories of low-impact and high-impact events and limiting the number of the latter permitted in city parks. Currently, high-impact events – those that have significant infrastructure, a commercial or for-profit nature, alcohol sales and/or a duration of three or more days – are limited to two per park per month.

City staff are recommending this policy be refined for Clinch Park and the Open Space during summer months, allowing – in addition to the National Cherry Festival and Traverse City Film Festival – just one high-impact event in those spaces in June, none in July and one in August. This would eliminate two possible event weekends from the summer docket downtown. Porterhouse Productions, which produces Paella in the Park and the Great Wakes Festival, already has a hold on one weekend in August 2014 for its events.

Some residents have also suggested banning Open Space events during summer holiday weekends, including Memorial Day, the Fourth of July and Labor Day. Commissioners could also consider raising permit fees and park usage charges, particularly for highly desirable locations like the Open Space, to offset impact and potentially reduce the number of interested renters.

Too Much Trash
Trash management emerged as a major challenge for the city this summer as the increased number of events – as well as record numbers of tourists – resulted in overflowing garbage bins, litter on the beaches and messy public bathrooms. While festival organizers are already responsible for trash maintenance within event grounds, city staff plan to recommend they also become responsible for trash “associated with their event” – even if that trash ends up off-site, such as in the downtown district.

“If the event holder wasn't removing trash to an acceptable level, the city would remove it and charge that cost to the event holder,” explains City Clerk Benjamin Marentette. “If this approach is adopted, city staff will discuss with each event holder...what the city's expectations are and how to move forward.”

Too Noisy
Perhaps the greatest number of complaints related to festivals in Traverse City have concerned noise pollution, as was the case with the recent Bayside Festival in the Open Space over Labor Day weekend, when residents reported hearing the event as far as 12 miles away at Bowers Harbor. Officer Scott Maxson of the Traverse City Police Department said that sound testing proved that Bayside and other high-profile festivals downtown this summer were all “within allowable limits,” raising the issue of whether the limits themselves will need to be evaluated.

In comments this month to the Central Neighborhood Association, which is studying the noise debate, Maxson explained the current policy thusly: “I get the feeling that people think if they can hear (noise) at all, that it's a violation. Most noise ordinances, including ours, as a rule of thumb are written to protect a conversation between two people approximately three feet away from each other. If either person had to raise their voice to carry on that conversation, then it would most likely be a violation."

In a memo to commissioners, Maxson outlined a number of options the city could consider to finesse its noise policy, including measuring frequencies utilizing different sound scales and/or equipment. The city could also vote to employ a subjective versus objective approach to the current “plainly audible” policy, which would allow noise control officers to make decisions about sound intrusion regardless of equipment readings.


Most Recent Comments

 
Erin S. - Masters Urban Planning UCLA on September 30, 2013 2:25pm

I think it makes sense to regulate the number of festivals/events, either by setting a limit on the actual number or by charging higher fees (and offering some subsidies to non-profit groups), so that some orgs are deterred and the City can use the funds to reinvest in the spaces where the events take place, etc, etc.

Just a resident on September 30, 2013 12:24pm

Festivals are great, but shorter ie, Film and Cherry Festival. Also, if the Festivals are making the city money it should be reflected in lower property taxes.(hint: they're not). Festivals may be great for some business owners (100). But, there are more than 15,000 residences that pay the price of traffic congestion, crowding, noise, police and other overtime, etc. Someone somewhere will ultimately ask themselves is selling the soul of the city worth the buck?

carol e on September 29, 2013 3:03pm

Is the bay and beauty of our region not enough? TC still needs to entertain ?

Also, I noticed that there is bee balm planted around the splash pad... so while the little ones are playing in sewer water they can be attacked by bees... hmm...

Jim Birch on September 29, 2013 8:20am

We are a tourist town and our tourist activity helps support all that we do and enjoy. If the tourist stop coming, the residents will have to foot the entire bill and that will not be met with great enthusiasm. Let the good times continue. Do I hear an "Amen"?

Handsome Dan on September 29, 2013 7:24am

I have watched TC grow into a dynamic vibrant entertainment area and I love it. I did not attend all of the festivals but I know tourists did. Trickle down economics works. Thank a tourist every chance you get.

KB on September 29, 2013 7:03am

There is NO longer a need to beg people to come to TC in July, hasn't been for 30 yrs. There is however, an economic need to induce them to come the 2nd weekend in May, when our hills and valleys are bejeweled in those lovely blossoms and our businesses are just crawling out of the long winter, and would welcome tourist dollars. From Jack Lane

Leslie on September 27, 2013 10:07am

I no longer live in TC but Open Space is "OPEN" not park, festival, high density people gathering blocking the openness of the Grand Traverse Bay for all. Not for profit's that have space for for profit businesses, is that still not for profit??? I and members of my family always enjoyed then open areas.

Anne on September 25, 2013 2:52pm

And, the noise issue simply has to be dealt with. I lived in a big city,yards from a major league ballpark. Not once did I have to button up my house and turn on the A/C or fans in order to avoid "enjoying" someone else's choice of music or movies and be able to enjoy MY choice of same with the confines of my home at 10:30-11:00 night after night. I live in TC, but not the immediate downtown area. It's ridiculous.

Anne on September 25, 2013 2:51pm

I am not convinced we need festivals weekend after weekend in order to be "vibrant" economically or otherwise. But,what I am most concerned about is the overuse of the OPEN SPACE by large-scale events that take up the entire park, charge $$ to get in, and pay extremely nominal fees to trash a public space in the name of economic development. I think the Open Space, or any of our other public parks should be fully open to the public most weekends in the summer.

karen on September 25, 2013 11:51am

This is not a shock to me. I do not like losing our cute town to festivals all summer. Why can't the fair grounds be used for some of this. so much noise by the hospital and nursing home? Common what are you thinking?

Local Resources
Classifieds

Classifieds

Real Estate

Real Estate

Obituaries

Obituaries

Marriages

Marriages

New Businesses

New Businesses

 
More News
Region's Least Wanted Invasives
Region's Least Wanted Invasives
Design Week Comes to TC
Design Week Comes to TC
What is FootGolf?
What is FootGolf?
Your Preview of a Crowded 104th Race
Your Preview of a Crowded 104th Race
Break-In at Toys R Us
Break-In at Toys R Us
72nd Rotary Show Opens Tonight
72nd Rotary Show Opens Tonight
Try Curling This Saturday
Try Curling This Saturday
New Looks, Brands for Downtown Traverse City Bars
New Looks, Brands for Downtown Traverse City Bars
your ad here