Traverse City News and Events

No Charges For Students Involved In Racist Snapchat Group

By Beth Milligan | May 5, 2021

Grand Traverse County Prosecuting Attorney Noelle Moeggenberg will not press charges against six students involved in a racist Snapchat group, she announced Wednesday. Moeggenberg said that while the students' behavior was "reprehensible, especially having come from such young individuals," it did not constitute a criminal act.

Moeggenberg was investigating a recent incident in which six students - five of whom were located in Grand Traverse County and one of whom was outside of Michigan - started a Snapchat group called "Slave Trade" and posted racist, homophobic, antisemitic, anti-disability, and other hateful comments about fellow students. The group assigned bid values to students of color, and posted remarks including “Let’s have another Holocaust” and “All Blacks should die.” Other students reported the group, prompting both an internal Traverse City Area Public Schools (TCAPS) investigation and a criminal investigation for unlawful posting of a message. Under Michigan law, unlawful posting of a message applies to online messages that lead to unconsented contact with individuals or to conduct that would make individuals “suffer emotional distress and to feel terrorized, frightened, intimidated, threatened, harassed, or molested.” The crime is a felony and punishable by up to two years in jail and/or a fine of up to $5,000.

Moeggenberg said that all of the students who participated in the Snapchat group were minors who made "repulsive, racist, and discriminatory comments." But those comments did not amount to criminal behavior, she found. "The statements, though extremely hateful, were not intended to communicate a threat, nor were they intended to place another in fear. This lack of intent is clear from the information received from those involved and is supported by the digital evidence obtained. In fact, it appears that the statements were never meant to leave the group. The statements only became known when one member of the group shared the information with others outside the group, including an individual who was named in the chat."

Moeggenberg said the lack of charges "should not be seen in any way as a condoning of the behavior." Instead, she said, "it is merely an application of law as it applies to the facts of this case. My office will make a referral for services to each of the local individuals involved." Moeggenberg concluded her statement by saying: "It is my sincere hope that counseling and training will help these individuals understand the impact of their behavior on others."

Comment

New Marriott Hotel, Senior Center Projects On Planning Commission Agenda

Read More >>

Hagerty Lays Off 6 Percent Of Global Workforce

Read More >>

Eleven Candidates Vie For City Commission Seat

Read More >>

Michigan State Police To Reopen Traverse City Post

Read More >>

Save The Date: Recess of Giving December 7!

Read More >>

Townships Use Moratoriums To Address Hot-Button Issues

Read More >>

Great Lakes Incubator Farm Receives Nearly $700K Grant

Read More >>

Last Call For City Commission Applicants

Read More >>

How NMC's Newest Degree Could Help Shape Water Cleanup Projects In Michigan And Beyond

Read More >>

Downtown Light Parade Rescheduled For Tuesday

Read More >>

Spotlight On Northern Michigan Artisans, Makers & Crafters

Read More >>

Curling Center On Track For January Opening; More Additions Planned At Kmart Property

Read More >>

Road Project Updates: Hartman-Hammond Bridge, Bluff Road, Veterans/Cedar Run/Voice Resurfacing

Read More >>

Snow, Freeze, Thaw, Melt: How Local Ski Resorts Navigate Big Weather Fluctuations

Read More >>